Pleiades Bee

Skip to content
  • Us
« Beautiful Sleep
The New York Times Motherlode Guest Post: The Perfect Backpack »

The Girl at the Park

Andy had an early softball game tonight so the kids and I met him there to cheer him on. And by cheer him on I mean I tried to catch him at bat at least once while watching Sophie climb all over the bleachers and feeding tiny cut-up grapes (dinner) to the boys. Schmidt Field has a nice playground area, and Sophie knows this. I think Andy was only into his second inning when I finally gave in to Sophie’s pleading and took the kids to the swings.

We had almost reached the playground when a little girl who looked to be about Sophie’s age ran up to us. She said she liked our stroller. She helped me push it. She tried to unbuckle Owen while I was putting James in the swing. Once the boys were in the swings Sophie pushed James and the little girl pushed Owen. She wanted him to go high. I said not too high. She listened. I noticed she was staring at the boys’ shoes. She looked up at me. She said she liked them.

I looked down at her bare feet, caked with dirt, bits of long-ago red polish on her toenails. Her plaid green skort and halter top were soiled and stained—and not the kind of dirty that clothes get after a hard day’s play. But the kind of dirty that clothes get when they’re worn often and not washed. She was missing an arm and as such her halter top was skewed sideways so that one nipple was exposed. She had a wide scratch underneath her chin and a small one above her right eyebrow. A young boy walked past—someone she obviously knew—and she scowled at him and said, quietly, “dirty bastard.”

I thought so many things at that moment. I thought about her home life. I thought about those words, “dirty bastard.” I thought about her mother. I knew her mother wasn’t there because at one point a teenager slowly walked over and said “Be good or I’m going to tell your mama on you.” The little girl scowled at her, too. I thought about the girl’s scratches and hoped they were akin to the bruises covering Sophie’s legs—signs of playing hard rather than hard living. Looking at the girl, I should have felt blessed with all I have but instead I felt ridiculous. I thought of my Amy Butler diaper bag, the expensive Stride Rite tennis shoes and sandals on my children’s feet, Sophie’s Dora-branded, fancy flip-top water bottle, the smart phone in my purse. Although I am not rich, I felt spoiled. I felt sorry for her. I felt sorry, for all of us, living in a world in which so many have so much and so many have so little.

Sophie, of course, wasn’t thinking any of this. She was just delighted to have someone to play tag with. The girls chased each other all over the playground. They slid down the slide together, hand in hand. They climbed up the rope ladder together and sat on a platform together and at one point, when the little girl was elsewhere and Sophie was swinging and fell, the little girl ran over, concerned.

They were friends.

Eventually the little girl joined some teenagers and children at a picnic table. And Sophie found someone new to play with. But when it came time to leave, Sophie insisted on saying goodbye to her. So we walked over. And said goodbye. Sophie gave her a hug. The little girl hugged her back.

We left.

While walking back to Andy’s game, still in progress, I asked Sophie about the little girl. Sophie said she had fun playing tag with her. And then she paused. I braced myself. For questions about the little girl’s missing arm. The scratches. The dirty clothes. The words, “dirty bastard.” And then Sophie said, “She wasn’t wearing any shoes.”

“No,” I said. “She wasn’t.”

“Well, I don’t want to wear any shoes then, too.”

The little girl was admiring my boys’ sneakers. Sophie was admiring the little girl’s bare feet.

I love the way very young children so quickly friend each other, without thought to sex, class, race, popularity, appearance. I hope Sophie maintains that sense of openness, always. Especially during those oh-so-difficult middle-school years, when absurd things like a shirt’s brand name matters. (And, let’s be honest. For many of us, it still does.)

And while I loved their short friendship, I hated the fact that I met a child tonight who was forced to wear such dirty clothes. Who was missing an arm. Who knew the words “dirty bastard” at the age of 3. It made me hate what I have. And hate what she didn’t have. And hate that some—many—have much, much more. And then I hated all the hate that was flowing through me. And so I tried to be grateful. Grateful for the two girls’ smiles and laughter, for their quick friendship, for their goodbye hugs. Grateful for what I do have, even if it makes me feel spoiled. Grateful I had the childhood I did and grateful my children have the childhood they do. And grateful that, despite it all, a game of tag is still a game of tag—oblivious childhood fun.

I hope I remember that little girl always. Especially on days when I want. And I hope I can embrace Sophie’s attitude and instead, turn it around and wish for bare feet.

“There can be no keener revelation of a society’s soul than the way in which it treats its children.” —Nelson Mandela


Related posts:

  1. Little Girl Legs
This entry was written by kara, posted on August 18, 2011 at 12:04 am, filed under All and tagged friend, playground, poverty, Sophie. Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.
PREVIOUS
« Beautiful Sleep
NEXT
The New York Times Motherlode Guest Post: The Perfect Backpack »

  • Brianklems

    This post exemplifies why you are one of my favorite people, Kara. I hope you know that.

    Brian

    • Kara Uhl

      Thanks, Brian. That means a lot!

      • Elgebhart

        I know it is tough to see children in dirty clothes, no shoes and we look at our children and see that they have a good life, a home, clean clothes and we wonder is life fair but we learn early on that life is unfair and that we should be grateful on what we have a home, family &  healthy children. 

         When I read your blog it brought up a thought from church.  Our church helps family in need that need food, clothes etc… Ed drives the church van to pick up 2 little kids who are like the little girl at the park.  The 2 little kids seat with us at church cause their parents won’t come to church.  We had a visitor that day and they sat in the pew in front of us.  She kept looking back at us.  She would look at Me, Ed, & our 2 girls and we all are dressed nice and the 2 other kids that Ed picked up.  I was wondering the whole time does she think that those are our kids who are in dirty clothes, not combed hair.  Or I am a mean step mother or foster mother. I just hope that she thinks that we were being kind and loving to the other 2 kids. 

        Anyway what we can do is embrace the children that come into our life and hopefully they will see that we are showing compassion and love.

        • kba

          I’m curious why you didn’t call child welfare? or the police? An unattended 3 year old? Obviously you cared for this child, but I’m curious about why you didn’t bring her condition to someone’s attention? I feel like I’m missing part of the story.

  • Jill Uhl

    I second Brian’s comment.  Kara, you are a wonderful, thoughtful person and parent.

    • Kara Uhl

      Thanks, Jill. :)

  • kdz

    So often your posts mirror some thoughts/fears/wishes I’m feeling, or have felt recently. I’ve been haunted by a recent shooting that closely affected a friend of mine at work, literally haunted by it day and night, and the way I’m trying to deal with it is to tell myself every night how grateful I am to have lived another day, for my children and my husband to have lived another day. It’s all we can do, right? Be grateful and not give into the fear or the hate or the wanting. Thanks for the beautiful reinforcement of that message.  

    • Kara Uhl

      Thanks, Kristin, and you’re right. I’m so easily haunted these days—sometimes it’s hard to not give in. I’m so sorry about your friend. 

  • Aaron M. Smith

    Very well done, Kara. I think a lot of us have been in that same situation, whether on one side or the other. Kids can teach us so much about life; they remind us of how things should be rather than how they actually are. I always enjoy seeing on facebook that you’ve added another post in your blog. This one was fantastic.

    • Kara Uhl

      Thanks, Aaron! And you are so right. My kids teach me every day. It’s incredible, really.

  • Aunt Cheryl

    Kara,
    This was a beautiful post, once again bringing tears to my eyes.  It is another example of the things you are doing right with Sophie. You are a remarkable mother.
    Love
    Aunt Cheryl

    • Kara Uhl

      Thanks, Aunt Cheryl. :)

  • Danine

    Thank you for taking a playtime in the park and an encounter of two small children into something that will help all of us grow up a little more.   Sophie and the little girl reminded me of how much we limit our life by not opening up our personal world. 

    • Kara Uhl

      Thanks, Mom. :)

  • Gary Gebhart

    I’m proud to be Kara’s dad!

    • Kara Uhl

      Thanks, Dad. :)

  • Pop Pop Uhl

    What did we do to deserve such a wonderful daughter-in-law? Oh, I remember, we had Andy! That raises the question: what did Andy do to deserve such a wonderful wife? That’s a tough one. ;-)

    Seriously, Kara, this was perhaps the most touching post of yours I have ever read, and that is saying something.

    • Kara Uhl

      I often wonder what Andy did to deserve me! Thank you, Marty. This means a lot. :)

  • Aline

    What wonderful and wonderfully written blog. I reminds me of the poem, We Pray for Children.

    http://www.oafccd.com/lanark/poems/hughs.htm

  • http://kidslive.wordpress.com/ Soha Alsaleh

    I love this post – so true, and so well written, it brought tears to my eyes

  • Pingback: What the Girl at the Park Has Taught Me – Pleiades Bee

  • Mimisphere

    Did it ever occur to you that this child was showing signs of neglect and should have been reported to child welfare?  Being poor and being filthy are too different things.

    • pleiadesbee

      Her feet were caked with dirt because she had been outside playing, barefoot all day. I disagree that dirty clothes require a call to authorities. Physical abuse? Yes. Verbal abuse? Yes. Lack of food and shelter? Yes, yes. But how can another parent be judged for not being able to afford to do laundry once a week? And perhaps her clothes were dirty from a hard day of playing outside? I know my children become quite filthy after playing outside for hours on a hot summer day, as they should! If I had truly suspected abuse or neglect, I certainly would have contacted the appropriate authorities. And I will, in the future. But she was happy. Is happy. Energetic. Eager to have a child her age to play with. And so that is what we gave her. And that is what we gave her the next time we saw her at the park (in which she was perfectly clean). And that is what we will continue to give her, as she and Sophie continue to play together.

  • Hope

    Can this little girl be found and someone check out her living conditions?  Surely, a little 3 year old with only one arm can’t be that hard to find.  Think she needs a better family to look after her and watch her more carefully.

    • pleiadesbee

      Hi, Hope. She did have several people at the park, teenagers and young adults, watching her. She goes to the park with a group of people and I’ve noted that they all look after each other’s children. I made note of that. If I had felt no one was looking after her, I certainly would have done something about that.

  • http://jomoseleysblog.blogspot.com/ Jo

    One of THE most lovely posts I’ve ever read! Sweet Sophie has touched my soul! “Children Learn What They Live”!!

  • Cyberdome101

    sooooooooooooooooooo sad

  • Helper

    Your article seemed self-centered.  Why think so much and just do something for her?  Give her your daughter’s shoes (You have a lot and she had more at home).  Give her some snacks but just talking about how you felt??  Not very compassionate

    • Marg

      Sheesh “Helper” – how do you know she didn’t give any snacks? How do you the two girls had the same shoe size? And what was Sophie supposed to do, walk bare-footed for the rest of the day? Stop trying to ruin a sweet story by your negativity. Even if Kara didn’t offer anything, this prompts thought in everyone that reads it, maybe causing those readers to want to and do something. 

      • rosanna

        that is kinda mean marg think before u speak mabey she just didnt want to hurt the little girls fellings

    • pleiadesbee

      Thank you for your comment. I believe she was barefoot because it was summer and hot out. The last time we saw her at the park she was wearing shoes. She had plenty to eat. The group of people she was with had a picnic table full of food and snacks. What she wanted was someone to play with, so that’s what we did. Thinking back, I wish I would have adjusted her shirt for her. She probably didn’t even realize it was crooked and that would have been a kind thing for me to do. But I don’t think she wanted for food. If she did, I certainly would have given her some. I’m sorry my article came across as self-centered to you. I was simply trying to reflect on the moment, and that two young girls from different lives were able to come together and enjoy each other, play with other, without dwelling on each other’s differences.

  • Jaquette97

    Did it ever occur to this woman that that little girl was being abused and neglected?  She should have reported it to the police or child protective services.

    • pleiadesbee

      No. After spending more than an hour with her and the people she was with (other children and people looking after her, including teenagers and young adults), I didn’t suspect abuse or neglect. Instead, I simply suspected she lived a very different life, a life in which she knows the word “bastard” at age 3. If I had suspected it, I would have reported it.

  • Brenda Caaviness

    Why didn’t you call CPS, buy her some clothes and shoes?  I would think your guilt about your “perfect” life would have driven you to do so.  Shame on you!  You had the perfect, God-given opportunity to help an innocent small child.

    • pleiadesbee

      Brenda, CPS didn’t need to be called as there was no reason to suspect abuse or neglect. Children run around barefoot on hot summer days all the time. Yes, her clothes were dirty but who am I too judge a mother who may not be able to afford to go to the laundromat once a week? And perhaps her clothes were dirty simply because she had been playing outside in them all day? (I suspected otherwise, at the time, but I’ve since seen her at the park wearing very clean clothes). What she wanted at the time was someone to play with. And so we played with her. And we’ve played with her since. And will continue to play with her. I don’t have a perfect life. No one does. And this girl has prompted me to donate more, give more, seek out volunteer work when before I would tell myself, I just don’t have the time. And trust me, if I ever suspect she needs or wants, I will help her. But in my essay I was simply trying to write about two 3-year-old girls, who lead very different lives (evident by the fact that she knew the word “bastard”) and yet those differences didn’t even occur to them as they played tag together. They were both happy. Together. That was what I was trying to write about.

      • CPA from Northern Indiana

        To Pleiadesbee:

        Your reply was a blessing. But, since you live in the Cincy area (35 minute flight on Delta), with proper authorities with me, all in plain clothes and from a distance, I would like to evaluate the situation independently. No harrassing, no involvement. the words used in your 8/2011 essay cannot and will not be taken for granted. If there is even a small chance that this young girl and her family need any kind of help, I will fund the needed help myself. Your words found the opportunity to “help just one person in life” and i am not going to let anyone drop the ball on this one. Find a way to reach me, or I can find a way to reach you, but there has to be an objective decision made if there is ANY help that is needed.

        • Christine Bates

           CPA: There are 2 types of people in this world the Courageous like you who take action to help. And the type like Ms. Uhl who make excuses to walk away.  This 3 year old child is Neglected. Ms. Uhl may not be aware that she can contact the police and not give her name and if indeed the child is fine than at least let the CPS decide this not Ms. Uhl. For whatever Ms. Uhl reason she has not taken the action that a caring person would. The fact is a child cared for is clean. A Poor mother goes to the food pantry and gets soap and washes her childs clothing in the sink, So saying who am I to judge if a mother can not afford to wash is very naive and incorrect on Ms.Uhl part. What is the reason Ms. Uhl has not seen the parents of this 3 year old girl? Ms. Uhl says she has seen the child many times in the park and her daughter has played with this 3 year old, Very odd the mother of the 3 year old has not introduced herself. Typically a mother seeing her 3 year old play with another child does start up a conversation with that mother. Very Very Odd. Nothing at all to do with class, as I have seen many times a variety of classes of woman and there is always without exception some conversation if the children play together.
          Please Ms. Uhl let CPS decide if this 3 year old needs help. One day and I say this as a Mother of 5 children, your own children perhaps as teenagers, or when they go to college, maybe in some type of situation where they will need  someone to help them, and will you want the person to walk away?

  • Paul

    I like your story but where was the little girls mother or father and why was she so unclean . Had she been the victim abase or kidnapping. Did you think to call the authortie? I see your thoughts and I feel for the girl also.Maybe I am just jaded I was abused by my father and no one know not even my Mom for fear he would kill my mom. We were poru but I was always clean you would never know we were by my dress. I have seen so much I my 57 years.The 9 to 5es as I call them they never notice anything but there little world.In whitch all is right and good . But sad to say there are way to many little girls and boys that have nothing . The one thing I had was my mothers love. We at times had no food or a car to drive but we had my mothyewrs love and I know the God was was wathing over me even though My dad tryed to take it all away, Sorry I went off here but you saw a little window on the truth so many miss seeing. Thanks for your story. May miny well see as you did what is real. I wouls like to know if you called the police to check out the little girl. My E-Maill is dipit@aol.com.

    • rosanna

      i feel very soory for u and your family and i think that was the sadest story i ever heard

    • pleiadesbee

      Paul, I’m so sorry for everything you’ve been through. If I felt like the child was being abused or neglected, I would have contacted the authorities. I have since spent time with the same girl, at the same park, and she was happy, cleaner and obviously being looked after. Please know that.

      • Christine Bates

         Pleiadesbee: I am sure you are a Wonderful person but no one is perfect. As a mother I ask you to please let CPS decide  if this 3 year old is in need of help. You do not have to give your name. Has the mother of this child ever introduced herself? Very odd if not. Typically if a child plays with another child the mother will always class has nothing to do with it start a conversation. This child is Neglected if a mother is poor she will go to the food pantry and get soap and wash the childs cloths in the sink, so it is not about poverty.

  • Vlancheta

    Loved the story, however God has called us to be a people of action.  It’s wonderful that you were grateful and reminded of how BLESSED YOU ARE, IT IS BETTER TO GIVE THAN TO RECEIVE.  I wonder if it ever crosses your mind that perhaps you could have done more????

    • pleiadesbee

      Thank you for your kind comment. Yes, but at the time, I felt like what she wanted most was someone to play with. And that I could give her. And that we continue to give, every time we see her at the park. But she has also inspired me to seek out more volunteer work. Of course I donate but, once I had three kids, I told myself I don’t have time to volunteer. That’s not true. I have time to watch a TV show at night. I had time to write this. So yes, I can do more and I WILL do more. And I plan to get my children involved doing more as well.

  • http://www.facebook.com/eeps.mangiofico Eeps Mangiofico

        You deplorable shit stained cum bucket!! Rather than basking in your synthetic seance of appreciation and naive borne again hope you should of been using your phone. What exactly is wrong with you that you couldn’t be bothered to pull your head out of your ass and ask some questions? Especially being a mother your self.
    Could you not be bothered to hang around while you wait for the cops?   I’m glad you can feel so fulfilled by the blights of others. You can rest easy that you did absolutely nothing to improve the life of someone completely powerless. Great job teaching your kids not to bother taking actions. Thankfully for your inaction mystery girl can look forward to being kept worm by abuse or addicts and there questionable deeds. If shes lucky she can deal with starvation and illness as she waits to die of exposure. Because of you we can have another aspiring damaged junky prostitute in the world. Five minutes of play is way more important than the entirety of a future. I’m glad there are people like you who can feel all fuzzy from dismal judgement.

    • CPA from Nothern Indiana

      I read the The Girl in the Park story three hours ago, and it hasn’t left my mind. All we need is the location and any other facts the young girl may have spoken to help the appropriate people find this little girl. People may like your story and how your daughter, as well as you, were affected. But that is not the REAL story. I believe there is still time to find this young girl and what family she has. Eeps response is spot on (thank you for telling the REAL story). But, let’s stop responding to a six month old story and try to find out the details (city location, park location, etc.). We CAN and MUST do something. Please somebody, get involved, or at least give someone the proper informatin to start the location task. This cannot be over. Please somebody do something. It is staring at you. Don’t walk away. I for one would help in any effort, physical or monetary, to help try and SAVE what Eeps graphically wrote about. If you are reading this, your life has reached a metaphorical fork in the road. Do you walk away and say it is someone elses problem, or do at least attempt to start in the help of connecting the dots to find this girl and her family. Let’s change a life. Please someone do something that other people can then help with. If this true story dies or goes unchecked, say goodbye to your country. It will truly be the beginning of the end.

      • CPA from Northern Indiana

        Eeps, do you have any specific information about the city and state, as well as the park information? I won’t allow us to sit back and watch. 

        • CPA from Norhtern Indiana

          To the UHL family, please respond to Eeps comments with detailed facts (call the police or local authorities since you know where and when this happened). You may not like the tone of Eeps language, but the message is as TRUE as the sun will rise tomorrow. Somebody please get us some information. Eight months has lapsed. It is an eternity in the the life of a child that needs help.

          • pleiadesbee

            CPA, We played again with the girl at the park two weeks ago. She was wearing shoes. She had clean clothes. She was happy and played with Sophie just the same. She was with a similar group, a large group of children, teenagers and young adults. I noted several of the teenagers and young adults watching after her. Again, their picnic table was covered with snacks and food. Just because she, perhaps, wanted nicer shoes or had a soiled top the first time I met her meant she was in danger. Rather it was clear she simply lived a very different life from my daughter. And yet they were able to look past that and still have fun together. Play together. Again, I PROMISE you if I suspected abuse or neglect in any way, I would contact the appropriate authorities. But you’re assuming things based on a 500-word essay (that I, perhaps, didn’t write clearly enough as your assumptions are wrong). Again, we saw her two weeks ago. She seemed to be doing great, and she and Sophie, again, had a wonderful time together. That said, it’s nice to know people like you, people who care this much, exist. Thank you.

      • pleiadesbee

        CPA, I so appreciate your passion and concern and I truly apologize if my essay has made you believe in a situation that simply doesn’t exist. I know what physical and verbal abuse look like. I did not suspect abuse or neglect. She had people watching after her. Yes she had bare feet. But it was a hot summer day. Perhaps you wouldn’t let your child run around in a public park in bare feet but who are we to judge? I’ve since seen her at the park, with shoes and clean clothes. Please see my comment above re the clothes. And the scratches. Trust me, I would have contacted the appropriate authorities if I believed this girl was in danger. But she was happy. Well-fed (their picnic table was covered with snacks and drinks). She and my daughter loved playing together. That’s what she wanted so that’s what we gave. Not all people have washers and dryers in their home. Not all people refrain from using phrases like “dirty bastard” around their children. Not all people care about wearing shoes in a public park. But that’s not for us to judge. Physical abuse? Yes. Verbal abuse? Yes. Lack of shelter, food? Yes, yes. Please don’t blow this out of perspective. My essay was not about a girl in danger. It was about two girls, who live very different lives, but didn’t even notice those differences. Rather, they simply enjoyed playing tag with each other.

    • pleiadesbee

      Her situation did not warrant a call to the cops. She was with a large group of children, teenagers and young adults, several of whom were looking after her. They were all sitting at a picnic table full of food and snacks. What would I have said to the cops? That there’s a child barefoot at the park? My kids go barefoot in the summer all the time. That her clothes were dirty? Who are we to judge the mother who can’t afford the laundromat once a week. In addition, perhaps I was wrong to assume they were soiled from not being washed often but rather from a hard day’s play? Should I have told the cops about the scratches on her face? My son slipped on bird seed yesterday, fell on cement and has scratches down his leg. She was happy. Energetic. I didn’t witness any physical abuse. Or verbal abuse. She had adults looking after her (not her mother, yes, but adults nonetheless). What she wanted was another girl her age to play with. And that’s what we gave her. If I had suspected abuse of any kind, I would have certainly contacted the authorities. Instead I was recalling a day spent with a girl who lived a very different life from my daughter (for example, my daughter doesn’t know the word “bastard”). And yet they were able to put aside these differences and play. Be happy together. Enjoy each other. That was the point I was trying to get across.

      • Dbtnply

         pleiadesbee:  I am a mother of 5 children we are not a poor family my husband is a senior engineer at a large company. However I volunteer at a food pantry 3 days a week and see  first hand proverty some of the mothers are homeless and live in shelters -they come to the pantry for diapers and soap, shampoo, etc… The 3 year olds do not wear designer cloths but they are Always clean and wear shoes. Taking food to the housing projects- not everyone has a car, I see a lot of children many 2 and 3 year olds I have Never seen the children without shoes or with as you described this 3 year old ” with dirty cloths that looked like she had worn them a few times.” I stay awhile and have a cup of coffee and conversate so I do see a lot and hear a lot I do not here the children cursing.

         You are Very incorrect to assume that proverty -poor mothers would not have the financial means to clean their childs cloths, the poor mothers may wash the childs cloths in the sink but they Care and  do not Neglect the child so they wash even if it is with a bar of soap.
         I understand your daughter has a playmate, and this you view as a important benefit for your daughter. Indeed having access to this 3 year old allows your daughter social time.
        You say if I thought the child was being Neglected I would contact CPS. You say the child is energetic.
        Children that are being abused also smile and are energetic.
         If you call CPS What is the harm? CPS will have a doctor examine the child. I urge you to allow a Professional to determine if this child is being abused in some way. You Never have to give your name!
         The next time you are at the park ask the child where her Mother is and walk up and introduce yourself this is done at Every park even in Manhattan where their are Many wealthy mothers, So class is not a issue,  you could suggest a play date say ” Our daughters play so well together, may be we could get together for a play date some day?” “Do you live close to the park?” At least you could try. If the mother of the child is there which is not likely , you could get a address and name.
        Certainly you must have wondered where is the mother?  You can also ask the child if the child says my mother is not here- who did you come to the park with? Than ask this person the same question that you would have asked the mother- the principal is still the same- you are a Mom who sees your child plays well the child.
        I think this would be great- a chance for you to go see where the child lives!

        I hope you do Something. Please do not just assume everything is fine.

  • http://www.facebook.com/eeps.mangiofico Eeps Mangiofico

    If you don’t do anything about it figuring someone else will. What keeps the next person from doing the same. If everyone figures someone else will handle it who is left to act? 

    • pleiadesbee

      But I don’t believe anyone has to do anything. If I did, I would do it! If I felt like she was hungry, I would bring her food, knowing where she plays most afternoons. I would bring her clothes. Bring her shoes. But I’ve since seen her at the park wearing shoes, wearing clean(er) clothes. Yes, her language was still rough. And yes, it was clear her life at home was, perhaps, much different than my daughter’s. But I truly believe it’s not one that’s filled with abuse, physical or verbal. It’s clear she’s well-fed given the food and drinks the people she’s with brings to the park (and that I see her eat). Just because people live very different lives from us, just because they may not wash their clothes as often as us or wear shoes in places we normally would … that doesn’t make their life “wrong” and our life “right.” Rather our lives are just different. Trust me, if I felt this girl was experiencing ANY abuse, I would do something about it. But I’m not going to call the cops on a family who seems to be raising a happy, energetic daughter who is quick to make friends on the playground and who might, at times, mutter the words “dirty bastard.”

  • Dochagar1

    Very touching story.  As much as I detest how Eeps expressed herself in her post, I agreed with her.  Why didn’t the mother ask where the little girl come from? Why is she so poorly kept?  More importantly why can’t she offer some assistance to that little girl.  I am saddened by the story and not touched by it.  Someone had said “you should only look down at someone unless you are willing to pick them up.”  Although, by the tone of the story, the mother was not looking down at the little girl, she forgot to pick her up.  It is sad to know as hard of a life that little girl may have had by her appearance, she still sees life as innocent, with a goal to make a new friend…and make it to another day without additional pain.  I would love to have met that girl, and given the chance to help her in someway.  Life is too short for anyone of us to humanize a sad story but forget there is a human involved in the story.

    • pleiadesbee

      Thank you for your comment. You have given me a lot to think about. I honestly don’t believe the girl was in desperate need of anything except a friend to play with. I have since seen her (and played with her) at the park and she was wearing shoes. Her clothes were much cleaner. Yes, her language was still rough. And it was clear her life was different than my daughter’s. But I don’t think giving her stuff would help that. Rather I think what she needed most, and what we continue to give, is friendship. And should I, for a second, even think differently I will be the first at her door with clean clothes, bags of food, money, whatever I can possibly do. But I don’t think that’s the case and I’m sorry if my essay made you think differently.

  • CPA from Northern Indiana

    To Kara Uhl:

    While I would love to give you my phone number and talk to you about the little girl and the location, there are nutcases out there who would be calling for all possible reasons. You don’t have to be, or required to get involved, but there has to be a way to communicate with you to the get the specifics of location, dates, words spoken, etc. You hold the keys to finding this little girl and helping her in any way the authorities request. But, the keys are eight months old, and it will take time and effort to find the girl and her family. Waiting eight months almost creats a “cold case”. Depending on the parks location, and the seasonal wheather, it is possible that the girl and family have “moved on”. But we/I must try and recreate that date last August and see where it leads. But, we can’t do nothing.

    • pleiadesbee

      There is no case. We played with her at the park again two weeks ago. She was wearing shoes. She was wearing much cleaner clothes. She was happy. There were several teenagers and young adults watching after her (which I noted). The picnic table, where her group was at, was filled with snacks and food. I’m sorry if my essay gave you the wrong impression. Again, I was simply trying to write about two girls who live very different lives but didn’t even note those differences, rather simply played tag together. If I, for one second, suspected abuse or neglect I would contact the authorities. Yes, my daughter has probably never heard the phrase “dirty bastard.” And yes, she said it. But that’s not a reason to call the cops on a family that, perhaps, can’t afford a trip to the laundromat once a week. 

  • Mlleq

    Great post Kara, it appears that so many people are reading neglect or abuse in between the lines. It did not come accross like that to me. Keep up the good writing!

  • sincere do good

    IT IS SO SAD THAT YOU CAN ONLY DISCUSS WHAT THIS ENCOUNTER MEANT TO YOU AND YOUR DAUGHTER.   HOW NARCISSTIC AND SELF-GLORIFYING THAT YOU THINK YOU “GAVE” HER WHAT SHE WANTED. ARE YOU A 3 YEAR OLD TOO?
    CAN’T YOU SEE PAST THE “INSTANT GRATIFICATION NEEDS”
    OF A SMALL CHILD?  SINCE YOU KEEP SEEING HER AT THE PARK,HOW ABOUT PROVIDING THE CHILD WITH SOME SHOES, CLOTHING, TOYS OR MONEY.THIS CHILD, WITH DIRTY CLOTHES AND BODY, MISSING AN ARM AND UTTERING INAPPROPRIATE LANGUAGE, NEVER MIND HAVING PRIVATE BODY PARTS  EXPOSED, IS FAR MORE BEAUTIFUL AND COMPASSIONATE THAN THIS PHONY, UNGRATEFUL. SELF-INVOLVED FAKE FAMILY.
    WORDS ARE LOVELY.  VOLUNTEERING WITH A PURPOSE OF GIVING   MORE THAN JUST YOUR “PAT-ON-THE-BACK” TIME IS TRUE CHARITY. PUT YOUR MONEY WHERE YOUR MOUTH IS.  GIVE ME THE NAME OF THE PARK AND THE  GIRL AND I’LL BRING HER SOME MONEY ETC. AND I WOULD GIVE IT IN A WAY WHERE SHE WOULD FEEL LIKE SHE IS DOING ME A FAVOR.  I WOULDN’T EMBARASS HER.  THAT’S BECAUSE I  KNOW HOW TO DO THAT.  I KNOW HOW TO  DO IT BECAUSE I HAVE EXPERIENCE DOING IT.  WHY DON’T YOU PRACTICE IT AND  YOU WILL GAIN EXPERIENCE ALSO AND LEARN HOW TO GIVE GRACIOUSLY WHAT PEOPLE REALLY NEED.  

  • http://www.facebook.com/alurathbone421 Christina Marie Schram

    From experience, I often had dirty clothes as a kid, I always played outside barefoot, and I almost always had scratches of some sort. Why? Because I was a kid, would refuse to where clean clothes and fell a lot! I think some people need to remember what it was like to be a child. Foul language could be learned from the television or from those around them. It sounds to me the the girl was just being a kid. I’m sure if Kara felt that the child needed to be in custody of social services, she would have reported it. 

    This was a sweet story. Thank you for sharing!

    • pleiadesbee

      Thank you, Christina. 

  • P2047447
    Kara Gebhart Uhl on Facebook Pleiades Bee on Twitter RSS Feed Receive Email Updates from Pleiades Bee Kara Gebhart Uhl on Google+ Kara Gebhart Uhl on Pinterest
  • Us



  • LINKwithlove
  • Things I Love

  • Archives

    • 2012
      • January (27)
      • February (10)
      • March (9)
      • April (12)
      • May (8)
    • 2011
      • January (18)
      • February (13)
      • March (18)
      • April (17)
      • May (14)
      • June (11)
      • July (17)
      • August (10)
      • September (19)
      • October (15)
      • November (12)
      • December (16)
    • 2010
      • January (17)
      • February (10)
      • March (15)
      • April (21)
      • May (10)
      • June (13)
      • July (17)
      • August (19)
      • September (21)
      • October (23)
      • November (14)
      • December (19)
    • 2009
      • January (21)
      • February (20)
      • March (25)
      • April (22)
      • May (30)
      • June (17)
      • July (27)
      • August (28)
      • September (19)
      • October (17)
      • November (20)
      • December (19)
    • 2008
      • May (22)
      • June (25)
      • July (26)
      • August (24)
      • September (24)
      • October (26)
      • November (20)
      • December (21)
  • Most Popular

    • Best Triple Stroller
    • The Girl at the Park
    • Simple
    • The Huffington Post Guest Post: Apologies to the Parents I Judged Four Years Ago
    • Our Chandelier
  • Tags

    andy art backyard birthday christmas colleen dinner discipline family fashion flowers food fort friends hair haircut handmade happiness health holiday James life montessori morning motherhood music Nini Owen parenthood parenting Paw Paw Pop Pop preschool sleep Sophie spring thanksgiving time tom tucker vacation wedding welcome winter worry
  • Email Subscription

  • Blogs We Read

    • A Country Farmhouse
    • A Herding of Dens
    • AndersonFamilyZoo's Blog
    • Baruth Blog
    • Can I Have a Breakdown After I Finish the Dishes?
    • Carrie Leonard Photography
    • Cincinnati Women Bloggers
    • Covert du Jour
    • Crush Cul de Sac
    • Dear Photograph,
    • dooce
    • Elsa Mora's Blog
    • Family Friendly Cincinnati
    • Flick's Friend
    • From Room 4 to Belize
    • Grass Is Bluer's Posterous
    • Jill's Jewelry Tales
    • La Porte Rouge
    • loft(3)
    • lovelydesign
    • Luci Wallis
    • Momastery
    • Motherlode
    • My Name Is Not Bob
    • not so random thoughts
    • Parentlode
    • Posie Gets Cozy
    • Pretty Stuff
    • Sam's Story
    • Science Cowboy
    • Soup Addict
    • Southern Momentum
    • Spyrou Chronicles
    • Sunday Nite Suppers
    • Surviving Motherhood
    • The Clidence Girls
    • The Life of Dad
    • The Meaning Compass
    • The TarBar
    • The Zak Family
    • This Year's Love
    • Whitmans' Sampler
    • wONEderland
    • Working Moms Against Guilt
    • writes4food
    • young house love
  • Dresses from Shabby Apple
  • Member of
    TheMomBlogs.com

Pleiades Bee is proudly powered by WordPress
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).